Those that follow Jose “Chille” DeCastro were not surprised on Wednesday when it was revealed that DeCastro delayed his criminal proceedings in Ironton, Ohio, heard opposition to his motion in his lawsuit against the city of Duncan, Oklahoma, and then made a number of moves to keep his lawsuit against two judges alive in a long-delayed Nevada lawsuit which may have proved fatal to that lawsuit.
Starting with the maneuvering in the Ironton case. Leading up to his scheduled hearing on Wednesday, DeCastro seemed like he was going to finally have his long-standing warrant quashed since he is still facing charges of resisting arrest, criminal trespass and disorderly conduct.
He had previously said that he had finally hired a lawyer to help get the warrant quashed but on Tuesday, a day before the hearing, that lawyer filed for a continuance in the case. It was delayed until January 14, 2027, with no details given.
DeCastro himself has been less than forthcoming as to why the continuance was needed especially after highlighting his hope that the warrant would be squashed on the original court date.
In other court matters, on Monday, defendants in his lawsuit against the city of Duncan, Oklahoma, filed a motion to ask the court to deny DeCastro’s motion for a quick decision on his motion to extend time to serve the defendants in the case.
This is the case where DeCastro filmed himself “auditing” police vehicles in a police parking lot in Duncan last year. He said he was attempting to gain entry into the police vehicles as he claimed that the long rifles inside were not properly secured.
DeCastro filmed his hand on the door as he proclaimed what he was doing and declared that he had the power to do so as part of his powers as a journalist and first amendment auditor. He then went into the police station and told police what he did and left after he didn’t receive much of a reaction.
Three months later, he was indicted on charges of molesting a police vehicle and a warrant was made for his arrest.
While DeCastro has successfully quashed the warrant by making an appearance through his attorney in the case, he faces trial for the three charges next year.
In the meantime, he is suing various city workers and police officers in relation to the criminal charges. However, he’s only served one person in the lawsuit, and her service is in question.
The defendants came together after DeCastro had not served any of them for over nine months and asked the Judge in the lawsuit to dismiss the case for now and let DeCastro refile once he can actually serve them.
DeCastro responded by stating that he didn’t mean to miss the deadline for previous extension to serve them and he could really really really serve the defendants right now, so the Judge should skip ruling on their motion and just let him serve them now.
Lack of service has been a key element in DeCastro’s other federal cases and will play a part in the next part of this story as DeCastro made several filings in his case against two Nevada judges who were responsible for his conviction of and acquittal from a conviction in 2024 which saw him do time in Nevada.
DeCastro began with a request to be allowed to file a new amended complaint in the case, admitting that he missed a deadline to do so imposed upon him by the court after it dismissed defendant Deputy District Attorney Agnes Botelho from the case.
From his exhibit 2, a version of which would be included as an exhibit with two of DeCastro’s new filings:
I am the Plaintiff in this action. I am over eighteen years of age and have personal knowledge of the facts stated in this declaration. If called as a witness, I could and would testify competently to them.
I am not a lawyer and have never attended law school. I represent myself in this case. I work full time as a journalist, and I publish videos on my YouTube channel, Delete Lawz.
I did not file a second amended complaint by the October 21, 2026 deadline set in the Court’s Order of September 28, 2026 (ECF No. 38).
I understood that ECF No. 38 granted leave to amend only as to the Monell claims against Clark County.
I believed that I should file one complete amended pleading, and that I could not file it until the judicial defendants, Judges Ann E. Zimmerman and Michelle Leavitt, had been served and had responded. Serving them took a long effort, including retaining a licensed private investigator, PL&E Investigations, in April 2026, and publication in the Las Vegas Review-Journal. I filed proof of service in October 2026 (ECF No. 41). Judge Zimmerman moved to dismiss on October 29, 2026 (ECF No. 44).
That belief was mistaken. I held it honestly, and I did not delay in order to gain any advantage. During the same weeks, I was working with my counsel on the opening brief in DeCastro v. Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department, No. 26-1594 (9th Cir.), the appeal from No. 2:23-cv-00580-APG-EJY in this Court. The brief is due November 27, 2026, and it has required a substantial amount of my own time and effort.
After Judge Zimmerman moved to dismiss, I understood that the sufficiency of my pleading would be decided now. I then prepared the proposed Second Amended Complaint and these motions as promptly as I could, and I am filing them on the same day as my opposition to ECF No. 44.
Had I understood that I could file a second amended complaint before the judicial defendants responded, I would have filed it on time.
The failed Power Ranger’s proposed second amended complaint was offered as the first attachment to this filing.
DeCastro’s second filing essentially asked the court to ignore the fact that he missed the October 21, 2026, deadline using the same reasoning as in the statement above. He’s new at this, he’s representing himself, it was an honest mistake.
DeCastro’s third filing was in opposition to defendant Ann Zimmerman’s motion to dismiss.
As with his previous filings, he relies on the argument that Judge Zimmerman singled him out for search before a hearing in the case. He acknowledged that Zimmerman had a right to impose a general rule where she ordered everyone to surrender their phones before the hearing but again doubled down that he was the only person who was physically searched.
DeCastro also claimed that Zimmerman’s reaction to his previous statements that he hated police officers and Zimmerman’s statement that she didn’t want to be a participant on his YouTube channel showed a bias that negated judicial immunity.
He also asked that if the court ruled in favor of the motion to dismiss, he be keep the John Doe Bailiffs in the case as defendants.
Attorneys for Zimmerman were quick to respond to DeCastro’s response to her motion to dismiss, pointing out a fatal flaw in DeCastro’s claims against her:
Plaintiff acknowledges that Judge Zimmerman announced a courtroom rule requiring persons who wished to remain to surrender their phones because only two requests to record the proceedings had been approved. [ECF No. 49 at 4]. He also acknowledges that the direction to empty his pockets was issued during his own trial and arose from his exchange with Judge Zimmerman in open court. Id. Those concessions resolve the functional inquiry.
In determining whether conduct is judicial, courts consider whether the act is a normal judicial function, whether it occurred in a judicial setting, whether it concerned a pending case, and whether it arose directly from an encounter with the judge in her official capacity. Duvall v. County of Kitsap, 260 F.3d 1124, 1133 (9th Cir. 2001), as amended on denial of reh’g (Oct. 11, 2001) (quoting Meek v. County of Riverside, 183 F.3d 962, 967 (9th Cir. 1999)). Those considerations are construed generously in the judge’s favor. Ashelman v. Pope, 793 F.2d 1072, 1076 (9th Cir. 1986) (en banc).
Each consideration supports immunity here. Enforcing restrictions on recording is part of maintaining control over judicial proceedings. The order occurred in court, concerned the trial then pending before Judge Zimmerman, and arose directly from Plaintiff’s appearance before her. [ECF No. 49 at 4].
Plaintiff’s proposed distinction between a general phone rule and an individualized enforcement order rests on his contention that the former governed everyone in the courtroom while the latter required only him to empty his pockets. [ECF No. 49 at 6-9]. That distinction is artificial. A generally applicable courtroom restriction necessarily requires enforcement against particular persons. The judicial nature of that enforcement does not depend on whether the judge directs a person to surrender a phone, turn it off, leave the courtroom, or establish that the person possesses no unauthorized recording device.
Judicial immunity is determined by the nature and function of the challenged conduct, rather than by examining the particular act in isolation. Mireles v. Waco, 502 U.S. 9, 13 (1991) (per curiam). A judge’s direction to officers remains judicial when it implements authority over a pending matter, even if the direction is alleged to have been improper or excessive. Plaintiff’s allegation that the direction amounted to an unlawful search therefore does not change its function: enforcing courtroom order and the restriction on unauthorized recording during his trial. [ECF No. 49 at 4].
They also note that DeCastro’s proposed second amended complaint would not save the flaws in his logic:
Plaintiff states that he no longer pursues injunctive relief against Judge Zimmerman. [ECF No. 7 at 15] [ECF No. 49 at 15]. His requested declaration concerns completed conduct rather than an ongoing violation. Declaratory relief that merely adjudicates alleged past violations without affecting future conduct is not an appropriate exercise of federal jurisdiction. Bayer v. Neiman Marcus Grp., Inc., 861 F.3d 853, 868 (9th Cir. 2017).
Plaintiff’s request that dismissal of declaratory relief be without prejudice does not affect the disposition of his damages claims. [ECF No. 49 at 14]. Those claims fail on absolute-immunity grounds and should be dismissed with prejudice because additional factual detail cannot change the judicial nature of the challenged conduct.
Plaintiff proposes to add allegations separating the general phone rule from the individualized order and supplying additional statements from the trial transcripts. [ECF No. 49 at 15-16]. His proposed second amended complaint does so. [ECF No. 47-2]. Those facts, accepted as true, show that Judge Zimmerman issued the challenged order from the bench, to a party, during a trial pending before her, and overruled his objection to it. [ECF No. 49-2 (Ex. 1) at 3:14-22, 5:17-25]. That is a judicial act, so the proposed allegations would not cure the immunity defect, and amendment would be futile as to the claims against Judge Zimmerman. See Sonoma Cnty. Ass’n of Retired Emps. v. Sonoma Cnty., 708 F.3d 1109, 1118 (9th Cir. 2013). The reversal of Plaintiff’s conviction [ECF No. 49-4] has no bearing on immunity. Stump, 435 U.S. at 356-57.
Concluding:
Judge Zimmerman is entitled to absolute judicial immunity for each of the alleged acts made in the operative complaint. For this reason, this Court should grant Judge Zimmerman’s motion and dismiss all claims against her in the First Amended Complaint. [ECF No. 7]. The damages claims should be dismissed with prejudice and without leave to amend, and the remaining requests for relief should be dismissed.
Finally, Magistrate Judge Brenda Weksler added a minute order on Thursday:
MINUTE ORDER IN CHAMBERS of the Honorable Magistrate Judge Brenda Weksler on 11/19/2026. This Court is in receipt of Plaintiff’s motion to extend time to file his second amended complaint. ECF No. 48. Opposition, if any, is due 11/24/2026.(no image attached) (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF – KNH) (Entered: 11/19/2026)
DeCastro is expected to livestream this weekend; it is unclear if he will make a statement on his pending legal action.
Share this:
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Facebook
- Share on X (Opens in new window) X
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
- Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window) LinkedIn
- Share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit
- Share on Tumblr (Opens in new window) Tumblr
- Share on Telegram (Opens in new window) Telegram
- Share on WhatsApp (Opens in new window) WhatsApp
- Share on Bluesky (Opens in new window) Bluesky



